Skip to content

← All articles

Collecting GuidesBaseballBowmanBowman ChromeRedemptionsRookies

McGonigle and Stewart Red RCs: Redeem for FanCash or Hold?

McGonigle and Stewart won Rookie of the Year, so their 2026 Bowman Red RCs now qualify for $100 FanCash. Which cards count, the deadline and the Cy Young trap.

Official Topps preview images of Kevin McGonigle and Sal Stewart 2026 Bowman Chrome rookie cards on a dark blueprint background titled Bowman Red RC, $100 FanCash or Hold
Published
Read
9 min

Kevin McGonigle of the Tigers and Sal Stewart of the Reds won the 2026 Rookie of the Year awards on November 9. That turns their 2026 Bowman Red RCs into cards that Fanatics Collect will take in for $100 in FanCash each, through March 31, 2027. You can also keep the card and hope for a bigger milestone later. Or you can sell it like any other rookie card.

Before you mail anything, check the exact card. McGonigle has a Red RC only in 2026 Bowman Chrome (#6). Stewart has two: 2026 Bowman (#6) and 2026 Bowman Chrome (#48). A base rookie card, a refractor, an autograph or a Topps NOW card is not a Red RC.

This week also brings a trap. Cam Schlittler and Jacob Misiorowski won the 2026 Cy Young awards, and both are on the 2026 Red RC checklists. Their Red RCs do not qualify for the Cy Young payout, because Topps marks both players as ineligible for Rookie of the Year and the program requires a Rookie of the Year win first.

Checked November 12, 2026, about 7:15 to 7:30 a.m. Central: the Fanatics Collect Red RC page and FAQ, the Fanatics Collect program article and terms page, three Topps Ripped articles, the official 2026 Bowman and 2026 Bowman Chrome checklist and odds PDFs, the BBWAA award posts and MLB.com's voting totals. The hero uses two official Topps preview images from Topps Ripped's 2026 Red RC coverage. They are shown for identification only. They are not store inventory. The blueprint background and title panel are original CardBoard Report artwork.

The award results

American League National League
Winner Kevin McGonigle, Tigers Sal Stewart, Reds
First-place votes 28 of 30 20 of 30
Points 204 170
Runner-up Parker Messick, Guardians (122) Carson Benge, Mets (107)

The BBWAA votes on the award and announced both winners on November 9, 2026. The Fanatics Collect FAQ names the BBWAA vote as the one that counts.

Which cards qualify

Only the Red RC version of a winner's base rookie card counts. Topps lists it on the checklists as a separate variation.

Player Product Checklist section Card #
Kevin McGonigle 2026 Bowman Chrome Baseball Chrome Rookie Red RC Variation 6
Sal Stewart 2026 Bowman Chrome Baseball Chrome Rookie Red RC Variation 48
Sal Stewart 2026 Bowman Baseball Base Cards Rookie Red RC Variation 6

McGonigle is not on the paper Bowman Red RC list. He is in 2026 Bowman as a prospect (BP-145 and Chrome Prospect BCP-145), not as a rookie, so there is no paper Bowman Red RC of him to find. His 1st Bowman cards and prospect autographs are great McGonigle cards. They are just not part of this program.

Each Red RC section on the checklists lists 40 players. The Red RC lists on Topps Ripped and Fanatics Collect mark some of them with an asterisk as ineligible for Rookie of the Year under MLB's rules. Because those players can no longer win Rookie of the Year, their Red RCs cannot reach the first tier, and the later tiers depend on it.

What the program pays

From the Fanatics Collect Red RC page:

Milestone FanCash
Rookie of the Year $100
1x MVP or Cy Young $300
2x MVP or Cy Young $500
3x MVP or Cy Young $700
Hall of Fame induction $1,000

You can redeem a card only once. Each tier unlocks only after the one before it. A player needs Rookie of the Year before an MVP or Cy Young counts, and needs an MVP or Cy Young before the Hall of Fame tier counts.

A few rules from the FAQ matter here:

  • The first window closes March 31, 2027. Fanatics says eligible cards must be received by the end of the window.
  • If the player never wins MVP or Cy Young and never makes the Hall of Fame, the card is no longer eligible after this first window. Holding past March 31 is a bet that one of those happens.
  • If a player later wins an MVP or Cy Young, a new window opens from that November announcement until the following March.
  • Rookie of the Year plus MVP or Cy Young in the same season pays a combined $400. MVP and Cy Young in the same season pays only the higher amount, in one window.
  • Each Fanatics Collect account can redeem up to 50 eligible cards per window.
  • The card has to be authentic and in fair condition, with no significant tears or major creases.
  • FanCash is not cash. It cannot be exchanged for money. Fanatics says it does not expire.

The two official pages describe the Hall of Fame timing differently. The Fanatics Collect FAQ says induction within 10 years of retirement. Topps Ripped's program page says within five years of eligibility. Fanatics Collect runs the program. If the Hall of Fame tier is part of why you are holding, ask Fanatics Collect which wording applies before you count on it.

The Cy Young trap

Cam Schlittler won the AL Cy Young and Jacob Misiorowski won the NL Cy Young on November 11. Both appear on the 2026 Bowman and Bowman Chrome Red RC lists with the asterisk for "ineligible for AL & NL ROY consideration." The Topps Ripped program page says Red RC players who win Rookie of the Year are the ones who unlock MVP or Cy Young payouts. So these Cy Young winners' 2026 Red RCs are not redeemable, and there is no $300 tier for them.

The same rule runs the other way for last year's winners. Topps Ripped says 2025 Rookies of the Year Nick Kurtz and Drake Baldwin have Red RCs that become eligible for the MVP tier if either wins MVP. MVP results had not been posted on the BBWAA site when we checked.

How rare is a Red RC?

The odds sheets print one rate for the whole Red RC section. They do not give a rate for McGonigle or Stewart alone.

Product Format Any Red RC, per pack
2026 Bowman Chrome Hobby 1:4
2026 Bowman Chrome Breaker 1:1
2026 Bowman Chrome Mega Box (two columns) 1:12
2026 Bowman Hobby 1:14
2026 Bowman Jumbo 1:5
2026 Bowman Breaker's Delight 1:1
2026 Bowman Mega Box (three columns) 1:15
2026 Bowman Value Box (three columns) 1:30

The Sapphire column on the Chrome sheet is a dash, so Red RCs are not in Sapphire packs.

A 1:4 rate is for any of the 40 Red RCs on the Chrome checklist. It is tempting to divide by 40 and call that a McGonigle rate. Topps does not publish how the 40 are distributed, so that would be a guess, not a figure from the sheet. Ripping 2026 Bowman Chrome now to chase a $100 FanCash redemption is a poor plan. The card's price on the open market is the number to compare against.

Redeem, sell or hold?

There is no right answer for everyone. Here is how we would think about it:

  1. Price the exact card first. Look up recent sold listings for the same player, product, card number and the Red RC variation, in similar condition. Use our price research guide. Asking prices are not sales.
  2. Compare that with $100 in FanCash, not $100 in cash. FanCash only spends inside Fanatics. If you would not spend $100 there anyway, it is worth less to you than $100.
  3. Add your costs. The program terms page Fanatics Collect links says the collector pays shipping, Fanatics does not reimburse it, and ownership moves to Fanatics once it receives and accepts the card. That page showed the basketball version of the terms on November 12 (see the note below), so confirm the baseball terms before you ship. Use our shipping guide and track the package.
  4. Decide before March 31, 2027. If you hold past that date and McGonigle or Stewart never wins an MVP or Cy Young, the card leaves the program. It is still a rookie card you can keep or sell.
  5. Don't hold as an investment. Future awards are not predictable, and this program is not a reason to expect a card to gain value.

How to submit

Fanatics Collect's steps:

  1. Log in to, or create, a Fanatics Collect account with your Fanatics ID.
  2. Start a submission from the Red Rookie Redemption page.
  3. Check that the card is authentic and in fair condition.
  4. Ship it by mail using the instructions in the submission flow. FanCash is credited after the card is received, verified and ingested.

This is a different process from Topps' ordinary redemption cards, which use a code you enter online. Our Topps redemption guide covers those. It is also separate from this week's Cosmic Chrome Supernova makeup.

A note on the terms. The Fanatics Collect terms page linked from the program article showed a basketball version of the terms on November 12, with NBA awards and different dollar amounts. This article uses the baseball FAQ on the Fanatics Collect Red RC page for baseball amounts and dates. If you need the governing baseball terms, ask Fanatics Collect before you ship.

Buyer checks

  1. Match the player, the product year and the card number: McGonigle 2026 Bowman Chrome #6, Stewart 2026 Bowman Chrome #48 or 2026 Bowman #6.
  2. Confirm the listing shows the Red RC variation, not the plain base rookie card. Ask for a clear front photo if the listing is vague.
  3. Be careful with "Red." Red Refractors, Red Wave, Red Lava and other red parallels are different cards. The program covers only the Red RC variation.
  4. A Topps NOW Rookie of the Year card is not a Red RC.
  5. Schlittler and Misiorowski 2026 Red RCs do not qualify for the Cy Young payout.
  6. If you are buying a Red RC to redeem, the purchase price plus shipping both ways should make sense against $100 in FanCash, and the card has to arrive before March 31, 2027.

You can browse TheCardBoardReport's eBay store for whatever is live. The store is ours. It did not return a readable inventory list when we checked on November 12, so this article does not link or promise any Red RC there.

Next reading: our 2026 Bowman Chrome guide, how to identify 1st Bowman cards, the Bowman Chrome Mega vs Hobby comparison, the Topps Chrome MVP Buyback guide for Alvarez and Crow-Armstrong, and the baseball hub.

Method and sources

Method: Card numbers and Red RC lists come from the official checklist PDFs. The 40-player count is a line count of each Red RC section. Odds are copied as printed and are per pack. No per-player odds, per-box counts, prices or print runs were calculated.

Affiliate disclosure: Some links on The CardBoard Report may earn us a commission. TheCardBoardReport also sells cards through its own eBay store. See our disclosure.

Explore cards and compare listings

Affiliate disclosure: As an eBay Partner Network participant, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through these links.

These searches cover the wider eBay marketplace. Check the year, format, condition, seller, and shipping date in each listing; search results are not verified inventory or guaranteed availability.

Browse TheCardBoardReport’s own eBay store — current inventory may include other products.

The CardBoard Brief

Useful hobby updates,
delivered without the hype.

Subscribe for verified release updates, checklist notes, and practical collecting coverage from TheCardBoardReport.

Free · Useful updates · Unsubscribe anytime

See how we handle your information in our privacy policy.